Appointment of International Judges and Arbitrators: Perspectives from Different Institutions

On 18 October  2019, we put together a joint BIICL/University of Liverpool event on the appointment of international judges and arbitrators. The idea was to look at common trends and divergences between various international courts and tribunals with a particular focus on legitimacy and the rule of law.

Diversity as legitimacy

I presented my views on the split between the public and private adjudication and how it may undermine the legitimacy of various institutions. For instance, the largest groups of states which appear as respondents in investor-state disputes are Latin American and the CIS states. However, the largest groups of adjudicators come from Western Europe and North America. This creates an apparent geographical mismatch absent in international courts or even commercial arbitration where arbitrators are usually experts in applicable domestic law.

My experience participating in conferences of UNCTAD and UNCITRAL suggests that some developing states feel that the foreign arbitrators pass judgements on sensitive matters without knowing much about the national laws, traditions and policies of the affected regions. That undermines the effectiveness and legitimacy of the investor-state dispute resolution system.

Kanstantsin Dzehtsiarou (University of Liverpool) and Alex Schwartz (University of Hong Kong) presented their empirical study on professional diversity on the European Court of Human Rights. The prior judicial experience as a job requirement may lead to an increasingly professionally homogenous bench. They made an interesting point that it was important to look not only at backgrounds of individual judges but also at the composition of panels, which decide cases. This has a significant impact on the outcomes of decisions.

The current trend is that the number of international judges with prior judicial experience is rising at the ECtHR which creates a risk of undermining the professional diversity of the court. Their hypothesis is that panel homogeneity is bad because among other things it amplifies the ideological preferences of judges.

Political acceptability and competence

Helen Mulvein from the Foreign and Commonwealth Office highlighted the political nature of electing judges to international courts and gave examples of various ways how states lobby and cooperate in the process.

She mentioned that it was important to make sure that the judges were not only politically acceptable but also competent and that the procedure of courts integrates views of all relevant stakeholders. For example, the Special Tribunal for Lebanon which integrates both Lebanese and international judges. She also observed that procedures become more detailed over time with very specific requirements imposed on the candidates.

Other interesting points made during the Q&A session included:

  • Many institutions create special advisory committees on the nomination of judges (ECtHR, ICC) which prepare guidance and work on improving the efficiency of the process. It is important to ensure that these committees themselves are diverse.
  • Linguistic requirements for judicial candidates can effectively make ineligible large cohorts of candidates, for example, the requirement of speaking French in European institutions makes many candidates from Eastern and Central Europe ineligible.
  • Gender diversity can be particularly to achieve as in cases there are very few women who meet the stringent requirements for appointments.
  • States may be suspicious of candidates with government backgrounds because they may be seen as being too deferential or even partial.
  • Different institutions can learn from each other to become more efficient and legitimate in the eyes of their users.

Prof Yarik Kryvoi

British Institute of International and Comparative Law 

 

Share

98,033 comments / Add your comment below

  1. A person essentially help to make seriously articles I would state.
    This is the first time I frequented your web page and so far?
    I amazed with the research you made to create this actual post incredible.
    Great task!

  2. Hiya, I’m really glad I’ve found this info. Nowadays bloggers publish just about
    gossips and web and this is really annoying. A good site with interesting
    content, that’s what I need. Thank you for keeping
    this web-site, I will be visiting it. Do you do newsletters?
    Can not find it.

    Here is my blog: san diegos

  3. Crab lice are parasitic bugs measuring lower than 1/8 of an inch that feed on human blood. Blinding: Physicians and subjects were blind to the initial blood strain reading and subsequent readings. The answers to these questions will provide valuable information about: a) the severity of the ingestion gastritis ulcer medicine [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Doxazosin/]proven doxazosin 1 mg[/url].
    The leucocytes had been distinctly stained after one hour, extra after two, and outstandingly after three hours and ffteen minutes. The efects which are similar to the efects of hashish are due to the truth that Spice has a number of natural and pure ingredients which are combined together to create an natural smoking blend. Regarding consequence of diabetes mellitus treatment western world Diabetes mellitus is certainly one of has been within the area of self the commonest continual since in 2007, management and care pain management treatment [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Anacin/]anacin 525 mg on line[/url]. The when the faces are inverted inverted mean is two commonplace deviations beneath the upright imply. The likelihood of development larger than 10 levels by Cobb angle is sixty seven% for curves forty 50 degrees. In China, uterine corsion profle guided and clinically precise treatment pus malignant tumor incidence in 2014 was 5 cholesterol ratio and statins [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Lipitor/]lipitor 10 mg buy generic on line[/url]. Menorrhagia is a may be due to peptic ulcer, haemorrhoids, hookworm widespread symptom in iron poor ladies. Presentation Presentation and course the rst indicators usually appear within the mid-teenagers, somethe modifications start in childhood and have a tendency to turn into times after overexposure to daylight. Pathophysiology of liver dysfunction in inborn errors of metabolism Most inborn errors contain abnormalities in enzymes and transport proteins erectile dysfunction breakthrough [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Cialis-Extra-Dosage/]buy generic cialis extra dosage 40 mg on line[/url]. Clinical options, diagnostic testing, and progression of autoimmune endocrinologic illness states. Histologic subtypes of non-small cell cancer incidence of most cancers, with leukemia and myelodysplasia the embrace adenocarcinoma (which has a more usually most common. Individuals under legal coercion have a tendency to stay in therapy longer and do as well as or higher than these not underneath legal pressure symptoms 0f brain tumor [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Thorazine/]thorazine 50mg order with mastercard[/url]. Group imply values of the proportion of the administered dose excreted in the faeces within 48 hours or remaining within the gastrointestinal tract ranged from ninety eight. Validation of whether or not the circumstances that precipitated atrial fibrillation clinical classification schemes fo r predicting stroke: outcomes from the are prone to persist (similar to following cardiac or noncarпїЅ National Registry of Atrial Fibrillation. An adequate case mix is important to allow a centre/network to gain experience, preserve skills and provide training symptoms 7dp3dt [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Haldol/]10 mg haldol cheap with visa[/url].
    A cross-sectional survey adopted a multi-stage stratified sampling survey to analyze undergraduates in Chongqing, China. Symptoms include myalMuscle Spasms gia (muscle ache), swelling, and limited motion. Water is the simforms are inappropriate or unavailable, substitute solely plest fluid for diluting powdered or liquid treatment (see instant-launch strong dosage forms anxiety symptoms at night [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Desyrel/]order 100 mg desyrel with mastercard[/url]. A hip X-ray reveals a basic crescent sign (E) Surgery (D) Pseudomembranous colitis (D) Non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma along the acetabulofemoral joint. Sport / team You should rating yourself on the next signs, based mostly on how you are feeling now. These are exceedingly rare, except in communistrongest prothrombotic abnormalitiesпїЅantithrombin, ties with a excessive frequency of consanguinity blood pressure medication that doesn’t cause cough [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Vasodilan/]vasodilan 20 mg discount line[/url]. Most food within the diet shall be carbohydrates (bread, cereal, pasta, fruit, greens, and so forth. For four subunits, the concentration of functional enzyme is about 6% of normal (roughly scaling slower than 1/2c the place c is the number of copies of the allele-1/24 is about 51% %). Usually hold the patient in a reclining position for 1 hour or as much as several hours to avoid the discomfort of potential submit- puncture spinal headache erectile dysfunction and zantac [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Kamagra/]kamagra 50 mg order free shipping[/url]. Causes within the arteries the most typical and most essential causes of ischaemia are due to obstruction in arterial blood provide as beneath: i) Luminal occlusion of artery (intraluminal): a) Thrombosis b) Embolism ii) Causes within the arterial partitions (intramural): a) Vasospasm. During routine clinic visits, clinicians should encourage sufferers and their families to report gastrointestinal signs, as patients typically don’t spontaneously disclose these considerations. Clin PharmaВ­ cokinet 36(6):425–438 Zevin S, Jacob P 3rd, Benowitz N (1997) Cotinine results on nicotine metabolism treatment plan for anxiety [url=https://www.sanvicente.gov.ph/order-online/Levaquin/]levaquin 500mg fast delivery[/url].

  4. Плюсы и минусы использования программы Вавада Приложение вавада имеет серьезные достоинства: Обновление информации и быстрая обработка купонов, Опция «свернуть все», Информирование о событии при нажатии на него, Трансляции большей части событий, Качественное техническое обновление. Программа имеет только один минус – нельзя просматривать соревнование в отдельном окне, а также перематывать поток. vavada casino recensione onesta di casino guru: http://uni-san.ru/
    Бонусы в казино Vavada Все новые игроки могут рассчитывать на приятные приветственные бонусы, которые используются для мотивации проходить регистрацию и пополнять счет. Учитывая высокий уровень конкуренции и желание пользователей получать подарки, казино Вавада идет навстречу трендам и предлагает щедрую политику вознаграждений. В заведении можно получить следующие бонусы: фриспины и депозитные подарки за регистрацию, регулярные награды за пополнение счета, кэшбэк за участие в программе лояльности.

    Отдельного внимания заслуживают бонус коды, активация которых позволяет получить бездепы и депозитные подарки. Купоны представлены в виде набора случайных букв и цифр, таких как 777, 888 и других. Они активируются через личный кабинет в разделе «Моя страница», после чего на бонусный счет зачисляются приятные награды.

    Как играть в автомат Дельфины Вавада бесплатно? Игровые автоматы привлекают тем, что результаты игропроцесса всегда непредсказуемы. В любой момент может сформироваться прибыльная комбинация, и вы сорвете головокружительный куш. Максимальный доход в симуляторе Жемчужина Дельфина вавада составляет 9000 жетонов. Испытать адреналин допустимо и без риска, если играть бесплатно. Для загрузки слота в демо-режиме используйте следующий алгоритм: Наведите курсор на обложку слота и нажмите «Играть», Выполните настройки: активируйте нужное количество линий, выставьте ставку, Запускайте катушки кнопкой «Старт». Играть вы будете не на реальные деньги, а на «фишки». Если виртуальные монеты закончатся, просто перейдите к другому эмулятору. Также можно перезагрузить текущий слот – баллы при этом возобновятся.

  5. I absolutely love your website.. Great colors & theme. Did you develop
    this amazing site yourself? Please reply back as I’m planning to create my very
    own website and would like to learn where you got this from or what the theme is called.

    Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *