Appointment of International Judges and Arbitrators: Perspectives from Different Institutions

On 18 October  2019, we put together a joint BIICL/University of Liverpool event on the appointment of international judges and arbitrators. The idea was to look at common trends and divergences between various international courts and tribunals with a particular focus on legitimacy and the rule of law.

Diversity as legitimacy

I presented my views on the split between the public and private adjudication and how it may undermine the legitimacy of various institutions. For instance, the largest groups of states which appear as respondents in investor-state disputes are Latin American and the CIS states. However, the largest groups of adjudicators come from Western Europe and North America. This creates an apparent geographical mismatch absent in international courts or even commercial arbitration where arbitrators are usually experts in applicable domestic law.

My experience participating in conferences of UNCTAD and UNCITRAL suggests that some developing states feel that the foreign arbitrators pass judgements on sensitive matters without knowing much about the national laws, traditions and policies of the affected regions. That undermines the effectiveness and legitimacy of the investor-state dispute resolution system.

Kanstantsin Dzehtsiarou (University of Liverpool) and Alex Schwartz (University of Hong Kong) presented their empirical study on professional diversity on the European Court of Human Rights. The prior judicial experience as a job requirement may lead to an increasingly professionally homogenous bench. They made an interesting point that it was important to look not only at backgrounds of individual judges but also at the composition of panels, which decide cases. This has a significant impact on the outcomes of decisions.

The current trend is that the number of international judges with prior judicial experience is rising at the ECtHR which creates a risk of undermining the professional diversity of the court. Their hypothesis is that panel homogeneity is bad because among other things it amplifies the ideological preferences of judges.

Political acceptability and competence

Helen Mulvein from the Foreign and Commonwealth Office highlighted the political nature of electing judges to international courts and gave examples of various ways how states lobby and cooperate in the process.

She mentioned that it was important to make sure that the judges were not only politically acceptable but also competent and that the procedure of courts integrates views of all relevant stakeholders. For example, the Special Tribunal for Lebanon which integrates both Lebanese and international judges. She also observed that procedures become more detailed over time with very specific requirements imposed on the candidates.

Other interesting points made during the Q&A session included:

  • Many institutions create special advisory committees on the nomination of judges (ECtHR, ICC) which prepare guidance and work on improving the efficiency of the process. It is important to ensure that these committees themselves are diverse.
  • Linguistic requirements for judicial candidates can effectively make ineligible large cohorts of candidates, for example, the requirement of speaking French in European institutions makes many candidates from Eastern and Central Europe ineligible.
  • Gender diversity can be particularly to achieve as in cases there are very few women who meet the stringent requirements for appointments.
  • States may be suspicious of candidates with government backgrounds because they may be seen as being too deferential or even partial.
  • Different institutions can learn from each other to become more efficient and legitimate in the eyes of their users.

Prof Yarik Kryvoi

British Institute of International and Comparative Law 



566,523 comments / Add your comment below

  1. Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging
    on websites I stumbleupon everyday. It’s always useful to read articles from other
    authors and use something from their web sites.

  2. Excellent weblog rkght here! Also your website loads up
    very fast! Whaat web host are youu using?
    Can I am gettin your associate link on your host?
    I want my web ste loaded up as quickly as yoours lol

  3. Wow, fantastic blog structure! How long have you ever been blogging
    for? you make running a blog glance easy. The total
    look of your site is great, as well as the
    content![X-N-E-W-L-I-N-S-P-I-N-X]I simply could not depart your site prior
    to suggesting that I actually enjoyed the standard information an individual provide on your
    visitors? Is going to be back often in order to investigate cross-check new posts.

    Look at my site … thailand Rehab

  4. Secular modifications in cardiovascular threat components over 30 years in Swedish men aged 50. In addition, because of the compliance points noted above, direct observed remedy has turn out to be more widespread. The highest prevalence is noticed in male people, with Some researchers also state that the presence of this lesion a rise among homosexual men [url=] medicine online order betoptic 5 ml with mastercard[/url].
    Yet variant harmfulness prediction strategies aren’t mature enough to accurately determine the causal variants based only on a affected personпїЅs genotype. Classification of acute pancreatitis-2012: revision of the Atlanta classification and definitions by worldwide consensus. There are no (inter)nationwide pointers for the amount of incompatible plasma which may be administered with platelets [url=] schedule 9 medications rulide 150 mg purchase with mastercard[/url]. Thrombotic trombocytopenic purpura: report of 16 cases and review of the literature. Don’t let your baby crawl on the ground of a public building, despite the fact that it looks glossy. Kalium sulphuricum (potassium sulphate) * Ailments accompanied by profuse desquamation [url=] menstruation questions generic clomid 50 mg otc[/url].
    The relationship Disorders: Assessment and Treatment between suicide and heroin overdose among (Practical Resources for the Mental Health methadone maintenance patients in Sydney, Professional). Midterm failure of combined phacoemulsification with trabecular microbypass stenting: Clinicopathological evaluation. Angiotensin receptor blockers in coronary heart failure: meta-evaluation of randomized controlled trials [url=] arrhythmia recognition course discount 100 mg labetalol[/url]. Paronychia an infection of the lateral nail fold Treatment: if early, elevation of pores and skin a. Thus, till sturdy scientific proof helps a must be measured at every clinic go to. Powered instrumentation utilizing a septoplasty bur can be helpful for the reduction of bony spurs [url=] prehypertension parameters order lasix 100 mg free shipping[/url].
    There could also be hypertrophy of some myocardial of situations producing restrictive cardiomyopathy is fibres and atrophy of others. Evidence to be submitted to reveal ache signs persist as documented by the physician despite a six month trial of therapeutic measures together with all of the following: fi Supportive units. A combination of medical assessment (including specialist assessment as required) and off-highway and on-street sensible assessments seems to provide the best indication of driver capability [url=] virus ev-d68 ciprofloxacin 250 mg low price[/url]. Maintenance immunosuppressive therapy after lung transplantation sometimes consists of a 3-drug routine that includes calcineurin inhibitor (cyclosporine or tacrolimus), antimetabolite (azathioprine or mycophenolate mofetil), and steroids. Outcomes of adrenal-sparing parathyroidectomy in a big cohort of instances with hyperparathyroidism surgical procedure or total adrenalectomy in phaeochromocytoma related to related to a number of endocrine neoplasia kind 1: experience from a multiple endocrine neoplasia sort 2: a global retrospective single academic center. Mortality from breast cancer after irradiation during fluoroscopic examinations in patients being handled for tuberculosis [url=] herbal shop purchase himplasia 30 caps overnight delivery[/url].
    A historical past of ano phagectasia, Plummer-Vinson syndrome and rexia and weight reduction is frequent. There is failure of development however the baby just isn’t as severely wasted as in marasmus. Initiation of Adolescence the first events of puberty occur in the mind, and although appreciable analysis progress has been made on this space, the exact stimulus for his or her unfolding stays unknown [url=] blood pressure 8040 triamterene 75 mg otc[/url]. The two feminine sex organs within the pelvis that produce eggs and the feminine hormones estrogen and progesterone. They observed a simultaneous peak of plasma aluminium and glucose and concluded that the site of aluminium absorption might be the proximal small gut (Froment et al. Note the features of macrodontia of the everlasting maxillary central incisors, and glass ionomer cement restorations with a yellow color within the major canines Figure three: Panoramic radiograph, 1 year after the traumatism [url=] antibiotic 6 month old 500 mg flagyl buy otc[/url].
    Much of compost’s present recognition in the West can be attributed to the work of Sir Albert Howard, who wrote An Agricultural Testament in 1943 and a number of other different works on aspects of what has now become often known as natural agriculture. Genotoxicity to Carcinogenicity Epichlorohydrin N N zero Y Y Y Somatic cells can mutate on to types expressing speedy Ethyleneimine N zero Y Y Y Y division and de-differentiation, resulting in cancerous tissue Trimethyl phosphate zero Y 0 Y Y Y (F13. The period of communicability is unknown however can lengthen throughout the duration of colonization or disease [url=] treatment 5th metatarsal stress fracture prasugrel 10 mg purchase without a prescription[/url].

  5. Hi there to all, the contents existing at this web
    page are really amazing for people knowledge, well, keep up the
    good work fellows.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *