Appointment of International Judges and Arbitrators: Perspectives from Different Institutions

On 18 October  2019, we put together a joint BIICL/University of Liverpool event on the appointment of international judges and arbitrators. The idea was to look at common trends and divergences between various international courts and tribunals with a particular focus on legitimacy and the rule of law.

Diversity as legitimacy

I presented my views on the split between the public and private adjudication and how it may undermine the legitimacy of various institutions. For instance, the largest groups of states which appear as respondents in investor-state disputes are Latin American and the CIS states. However, the largest groups of adjudicators come from Western Europe and North America. This creates an apparent geographical mismatch absent in international courts or even commercial arbitration where arbitrators are usually experts in applicable domestic law.

My experience participating in conferences of UNCTAD and UNCITRAL suggests that some developing states feel that the foreign arbitrators pass judgements on sensitive matters without knowing much about the national laws, traditions and policies of the affected regions. That undermines the effectiveness and legitimacy of the investor-state dispute resolution system.

Kanstantsin Dzehtsiarou (University of Liverpool) and Alex Schwartz (University of Hong Kong) presented their empirical study on professional diversity on the European Court of Human Rights. The prior judicial experience as a job requirement may lead to an increasingly professionally homogenous bench. They made an interesting point that it was important to look not only at backgrounds of individual judges but also at the composition of panels, which decide cases. This has a significant impact on the outcomes of decisions.

The current trend is that the number of international judges with prior judicial experience is rising at the ECtHR which creates a risk of undermining the professional diversity of the court. Their hypothesis is that panel homogeneity is bad because among other things it amplifies the ideological preferences of judges.

Political acceptability and competence

Helen Mulvein from the Foreign and Commonwealth Office highlighted the political nature of electing judges to international courts and gave examples of various ways how states lobby and cooperate in the process.

She mentioned that it was important to make sure that the judges were not only politically acceptable but also competent and that the procedure of courts integrates views of all relevant stakeholders. For example, the Special Tribunal for Lebanon which integrates both Lebanese and international judges. She also observed that procedures become more detailed over time with very specific requirements imposed on the candidates.

Other interesting points made during the Q&A session included:

  • Many institutions create special advisory committees on the nomination of judges (ECtHR, ICC) which prepare guidance and work on improving the efficiency of the process. It is important to ensure that these committees themselves are diverse.
  • Linguistic requirements for judicial candidates can effectively make ineligible large cohorts of candidates, for example, the requirement of speaking French in European institutions makes many candidates from Eastern and Central Europe ineligible.
  • Gender diversity can be particularly to achieve as in cases there are very few women who meet the stringent requirements for appointments.
  • States may be suspicious of candidates with government backgrounds because they may be seen as being too deferential or even partial.
  • Different institutions can learn from each other to become more efficient and legitimate in the eyes of their users.

Prof Yarik Kryvoi

British Institute of International and Comparative Law 



197,035 comments / Add your comment below

  1. I’ve been browsing online more than 4 hours today, yet I never
    found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me.
    Personally, if all website owners and bloggers made
    good content as you did, the internet will be a lot more useful than ever before.

  2. Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Thank you so much, However
    I am having problems with your RSS. I don?t
    know why I can’t join it. Is there anyone else getting the
    same RSS problems? Anybody who knows the solution will you kindly respond?


    my web blog :: disney dining

  3. Urticaria Care Pathway: Further Assessment and Management – Adjust Medication/Advice, Monitor Symptoms, Onward Referral. Tryptase Almost all human mast cells make and retailer the immunoassay end result for complete tryptase reflects tryptases which represent the main proteins in the mast cell number and measures professional and mature the secretory granules. Thrombotic microangiopathy within the most cancers affected person including these induced by chemotherapeutic brokers gastritis tips [url=]30 caps diarex buy mastercard[/url].
    Cholesterol emboli are common complication publish angiographic procedures and often there are eosinophils within the urine. Whereas a single syncopal episode, when the analysis is safe, needn’t preclude certification, a historical past of repeated or clustered attacks will usually lead to loss of medical health. Also, advise the patient that the prescribing data is available to her upon request muscle relaxant for bruxism [url=]500 mg methocarbamol cheap with amex[/url]. Organ/Tissue Transplants at Blue Distinction Centers for Transplants We participate in the Blue Distinction Centers for Transplants Program for the organ/tissue transplants listed below. Some kinds of sphingolipids are typically discovered throughout the central nervous system, and therefore abnormal accumulation of those sub- stances produces neurologic indicators and symptoms. Histopathology reveals granulomatous lesions, associated with crypt abscesses, fissures, and aphthous ulcers with submucosal extensions treatment 247 [url=]buy levaquin 250 mg low cost[/url]. A 3-month-old boy is brought to the emergency department because of a 2-hour history of respiratory distress. Guillain-Barre syndrome, Miller-Fisher syndrome, acute sensory ataxic neuropathy). Visit Profile sheets should be utilized by most active duty patients for the dental clinic, most non-sickcall visits (except refill or filling outside prescription), health profit visits, weight checks, follow-up lab testing, immunizations, allergy photographs, audiogram, and so forth muscle relaxant reviews [url=]generic voveran 50 mg without a prescription[/url]. Postpartum, Subacute, and Silent Thyroiditis barrierforT business assays 3 these circumstances cause thyroid infammation with release Acute psychiatric problems Autonomous thyroid or thyroid (30%) nodule of saved hormone. Patients who fulfil the criteria could then be positioned on a ready record according to their scientific want. Child Disorder in Adolescents: A Systematic and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics of North Review medications high blood pressure [url=]purchase coversyl 4mg with amex[/url]. Before discussing the particular steps you ment and machinery regularly, and make sure can take to keep away from a lawsuit, listed below are two terms that subordinates use them competently and you have to know more about: negligence and safely. The white parts of the eyes turn into pink or red, the eyes might damage, really feel itchy or scratchy, and so they may produce lots of tears and discharge. It can also be important to determine whether or not the unit intends to discharge all patients on the same day as its standard apply, or whether or not in a single day stays are permitted spasms urethra [url=]tegretol 100 mg discount without prescription[/url].
    WernickeпїЅs syndrome or Wernicke encephalopathy: Usually begins at forty eight to seventy two hours, but can be delayed Neurological disease characterised by the clinical triad up to four to 5 days. Keratinization additionally Dunk child carrots in a tablespoon of (xero = dry, ophthalm = eye). For an accurate di erential analysis of different adnexal lesions, every case should be positioned in its applicable medical context gastritis diet электронное [url=]generic pantoprazole 40 mg mastercard[/url]. Typically, that is extra prone to occur towards the top of the grazing season, ie. Decision support Accessible guidelines for diabetes management and related points. Predust usually is a fine, dry material composed of wheat flour, gums, Heat treated fishery products 73 proteins and infrequently flavours, which is sprinkled on the moist surface of the frozen or recent seafood erectile dysfunction latest medicine [url=]fildena 25 mg generic on-line[/url]. In the following sections, I focus on the recent research on a number of phenomena that appear to call for a resurrection of a model of the Lamarckian state of affairs as an important contribution to the genome and organism evolution. In vitro evaluation of arsenic bioaccessibility in contaminated (anthropogenic and geogenic) soils. Another important talent is ordering, similar to understanding the sequence of a protein or a nucleic acid; the sequence of genes along a chromosome; the pecking order of a hierarchically organized social group inside a chicken coop; the trophic ranges from producers to major, secondary, tertiary customers in a meals chain; or the substrate- product series of metabolic pathways or signal cascades journal of women’s health issues & care [url=]discount femara 2.5 mg free shipping[/url]. A full blood cell rely is the first test for assessing a defect of the mobile immune system, as some issues are characterized by lymphopenia. The trial concerned couples with unexplained infertility who had had no earlier treatment. Applying the Hayes high quality checklist system for score the quality of individual research, we rated the quality of individual studies as fair for the outcome of motor operate however poor for all other outcomes symptoms vs signs [url=]discount chloromycetin 250 mg otc[/url].

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *